Sub advice

[djwhog]

F212 or a Gotham, no seriously a pair of small JL subs would be great, you will never look back or 2nd guess....

Sent from my iPad using A.Aficionado

[bigblue]

I have a couple of Velodyne's my self (although a different model) and are happy with the sound in comparison with the small foot print. My friend has the large Sunfire and is equally happy. In your case, as you already had what you consider the full sub experience , I would go with either one of them. You will never get close to what you had before in any case. So just pick one, be happy with it and enjoy the new set up.

[harri009]

Originally Posted by bigblue

I have a couple of Velodyne's my self (although a different model) and are happy with the sound in comparison with the small foot print. My friend has the large Sunfire and is equally happy. In your case, as you already had what you consider the full sub experience , I would go with either one of them. You will never get close to what you had before in any case. So just pick one, be happy with it and enjoy the new set up.

Thanks, yeah the point of the question wasn't what would be the ultimate sub but which of these value subs I listed would offer the best thump for the money. I won't be playing these with any music whatsoever. I appreciate your response as your the only one who tried to answer the actual question. May I ask which velodyne you own?

[Cohibaman]

I don't know the models offhand, but I'm using both a Definitive Technology and a Velodyne. Even though they're older, they do a descent job with thump in their respective surround sound systems.

[eljr]

Originally Posted by harri009

Looking to buy a small subwoofer to replace my SVS PB13 I recently sold. I needed to open some space. The ones I am contemplating are below. Anyone heard all of any of these and have a suggestion as to which of the 4?

Sunfire HRS, XTEQ
Definitive Technology supercube
Velodyne Minivee
SVS SB-2000

These top three brands would be who I can buy from and they are pretty much the main companies making small package subs. The SVS does have a low enough cost at $629 B-stock and no measurements over 16". Oh and No measurement can go over 16" will work . I wasn't planning to replace the SVS with anything but figured I could throw something relatively inexpensive in and get most the bass I had since I am only in a little 10x10.

from this list, SVS SB-2000 is the best choice

Originally Posted by Masterlu

JL E sub...

this seems a great choice... except for the price

Originally Posted by Audiofan1

Rythmik subs may do nicely!

Rythmik Audio servo subwoofer 12" F12

excellent idea

[harri009]

Originally Posted by eljr

from this list, SVS SB-2000 is the best choice this seems a great choice... except for the price excellent idea

Thanks, have you ever compared/heard them? I wonder how far up the lines of the other companies (def tech, sunfire) the 2000 would climb before being beaten. I also looked into HSU a little but none of their subs meet the space requirements I am after.

[harri009]

Originally Posted by Cohibaman

I don't know the models offhand, but I'm using both a Definitive Technology and a Velodyne. Even though they're older, they do a descent job with thump in their respective surround sound systems.

Thanks

[bigblue]

Originally Posted by harri009

Thanks, yeah the point of the question wasn't what would be the ultimate sub but which of these value subs I listed would offer the best thump for the money. I won't be playing these with any music whatsoever. I appreciate your response as your the only one who tried to answer the actual question. May I ask which velodyne you own?

As you can see in my signature, I have dual Velodyne DD10. What I like about them is the umf you get from "just" a 10 inch woofer and the awesome 6 band parametric eq. That thing helps a lot in getting the best out of the boxes.

[harri009]

I hate you guys.....

Just blew my budget today and bought the JL E112.

[Cohibaman]

Originally Posted by harri009

I hate you guys.....

Just blew my budget and bought the JL E112.

Congrats though!