Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark J
I don't have a problem with it being called a quasi-ribbon. I have a problem with stating it is an "all-ribbon" speaker with a parenthetical mention that it is actually a quasi-ribbon.
There is a big difference between these two. One uses Mylar to produce the sound driven by the magnetic motor of flat wire (quasi-ribbons) and a magnetic field while the other is a true ribbon producing the sound.
With Magneplanar producing speakers with quasi-ribbons and true ribbons, I would think that they would appreciate an accurate description of their product to help the consumer avoid the confusion.
Sure it makes a fancy introduction but it allows misinterpretation which can spread misinformation.
|
Mark, I'm sure you are correct, but I think it worthy of note that Magnepan, the manufacturer of the speaker, headlines its own advertisement for the 1.7 as:
The First Full Range Ribbon Speaker from Magnepan
And, further down in the ad, Magnepan states:
"The 1.7 is a departure from Magnepan's 40 year history of using planar magnetic drivers for the bass or lower midrange. The use of quasi ribbon technology down into the lower midrange and bass provides a new level of coherence."
"The 1.7 also boasts a quasi ribbon super tweeter with a wider "sweet spot" and a step closer to the delicacy and detail of Magnepan's true ribbon design."
This is a
Magnepan Incorporated advertisement that appears on page 47 in the March 2010 issue (Issue 201) of
The Absolute Sound.
Now, Mark J. I find it difficult to argue with the manufacturer on their terminology, since they were easily one of the first to implement planar technology in their speakers, some 40 years ago. And, I guess they can call their new products whatever they want to.
Obviously, Mr. Valin stated exactly the information that Magnepan (Magneplanar) had furnished relative to the description of their product. Therefore his was an "accurate description" and should not cause confusion.