Analog Addict |
07-20-2016 07:46 AM |
I asked Dennis about parallel single ended design, and he was kind enough to send me a lengthy response detailing his thoughts. So now you know....
Here are just a few of my thoughts from experience with single-ended parallel tubes in class A amplifier circuits. First and foremost keep in mind the additional output power derived is not the key factor. As you and I both know very well 5 watts or so is an excellent usable power level for home audio providing the amplifier is of a single-ended class A tube design. Moving up the power level scale does not truly gain a lot of realized SPL level until you increase that 5 or so wattage level to 50 watts which will gain a 10dB addition SPL output level. In my opinion if one truly needs this higher 50- 100 watt level they might as well go with a 200 watt solid state ear bleeder. The extraordinary level of musical emotion presented by a single-ended class A tube amplifier in my opinion is saved for the music lover and not a head-banger, show-off! My audio, in the business experience, reveals very clearly that after a few weeks with a high power, hi-fi spectacular, impress your buddies system is in most cases turned off and ends up collecting dust. Just check out Audiogon and Ebay … the high power in your face noise making gear is up for sale by the boat loads.
Sorry for the soap box ….. after all these years I still have a passion for the musical presentation in a memorable, emotional manner. I only know how to present this musical experience in a home audio environment with single-ended tube audio. Since I was a kid starting with my first single-ended 6V6 class A audio amplifier. I simply do not know any better!!!!!!!!!!
Anyway … the advantages of multiple tubes in parallel SE a numerous. First the transformation ratio of the high impedance plate resistance of the vacuum tubes is lowered by additional tubes combining as one load to the primary output transformer winding. This ratio between the vacuum tube and the driving loudspeaker is lower. This lower ratio equates to great control of the system loudspeaker. The available dynamic peak envelope power is considerable greater with the load being shared by additional tubes in the output stage along with additional plate voltage because of the lower primary impedance. One of the absolute key factors … and once again in my opinion ….. is a lower distortion level at that actual user level of power. If one needs all of the 17 watts for instance in the new parallel KT88 PSE amp they might as well get a high power solid state amp. What I am saying … at the level of 5 or 8 watts that is usually more than adequate for the home environment … the distortion curve is mush lower with the 17 watt amplifier than using all the available power in the 5 or 8 watt total single tube amp. So your are gaining control and lower distortion in the usable power range. As far as bias is concerned in my designs I use individual cathode auto bias on each tube. The tube itself reaches the proper bias level no matter the brand or even the condition of the tube. Now the output transformer becomes even more critical as additional tubes are run in parallel. The current thru the transformer increase by each additional tube added and the impedance of the primary lowers as well. With grain oriental impregnated silicon steel luminance and high temperate wire insulation some very nice single-ended, air gap output transformers can be designed and wound. The transformers I have wound for these amps contain wire insulation with rating temps of 220 C and silver soldered Teflon lead outs. Run this new amp at the 5 to 10 watt level and I gotta tell ya the dynamic range and speaker control is exciting.
|