AudioAficionado.org

AudioAficionado.org (https://www.audioaficionado.org/index.php)
-   Wilson Audio (https://www.audioaficionado.org/forumdisplay.php?f=66)
-   -   Tried reverse polarity on my sasha 2 (https://www.audioaficionado.org/showthread.php?t=46491)

Supermerio 08-23-2019 05:34 AM

Tried reverse polarity on my sasha 2
 
Tried reverse polarity (mids and highs ) on my sasha 2, suprisingly it
Sounded more natural to my ears. Phase and time coherence suffered,
Smaller soundstage, a little drier sounding, but to my ears mids sounded
More natural without that “revered” type of mids, it also became forward with
A denser or more meat voicing, a little less air and less sweeter top.

Overall; it sounded good but a little boring to my ears. I still like the
Non inverted polarity but i can live with this set up since it wlso
Sounded very good!

Hope i made a meaningful contribution with my ist thread.


Elmer

krell-diva 08-23-2019 01:12 PM

I suspect, on the pleasing side you are just reducing the upper bass/boom from the coupling the woofers and midrange driver.
You can pare down those woofers with a smaller value resistor.
But overall most likely better sound when in phase.

metaphacts 08-23-2019 04:29 PM

Just a quick question. Do you check for correct (best?) absolute polarity on every recording?

Supermerio 08-24-2019 12:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by krell-diva (Post 977174)
I suspect, on the pleasing side you are just reducing the upper bass/boom from the coupling the woofers and midrange driver.
You can pare down those woofers with a smaller value resistor.
But overall most likely better sound when in phase.


With sasha 2; you can only out of phase both midrange and tweeter
Since both wiring is already exposed. There is no way to adjust
The woofers without opening the box, you may be right though
That there might me some losses which frankly speaking?, im
Not good at detecting.

My point really is that this is the only speakers that i have or had
That sounded very good on either polarity, others sounded odd or dis
Torted.

Elmer

Supermerio 08-24-2019 01:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by metaphacts (Post 977197)
Just a quick question. Do you check for correct (best?) absolute polarity on every recording?

Bill

I never do. Why the question? My dac though has the adjustment
For both negative and positive phase, don’t know if this has the
Same effect.

Elmer

metaphacts 08-24-2019 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supermerio (Post 977244)
Bill

I never do. Why the question? My dac though has the adjustment
For both negative and positive phase, don’t know if this has the
Same effect.

Elmer

Hi Elmer,

When you reverse the leads as you have done, you have placed the mids in the incorrect acoustic (not to be confused with electrical) phase relative to the woofers at the listening position. That is, you have misaligned the mids to the woofer. What you like is up to you, but over time this configuration should show up as completely incorrect in timing, integration, staging and tonal balance.

Someone suggested altering resistor values in the bass modules. The right course of action is to revisit set up. I would bet that the speaker is not correctly positioned relative to the bass to mid transition. At the end of the WASP set up process, you are talking small fractions of an inch.

Absolute polarity is different and is based on the polarity of signal being maintained at the speaker output relative to the original mic feed(s). It is based on each individual recording. Properly set up Sasha 2s should show obvious differences between positive and inverted polarity on most tracks. If they do not, see above.

Bill

Supermerio 08-24-2019 10:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by metaphacts (Post 977267)
Hi Elmer,

When you reverse the leads as you have done, you have placed the mids in the incorrect acoustic (not to be confused with electrical) phase relative to the woofers at the listening position. That is, you have misaligned the mids to the woofer. What you like is up to you, but over time this configuration should show up as completely incorrect in timing, integration, staging and tonal balance.

Someone suggested altering resistor values in the bass modules. The right course of action is to revisit set up. I would bet that the speaker is not correctly positioned relative to the bass to mid transition. At the end of the WASP set up process, you are talking small fractions of an inch.

Absolute polarity is different and is based on the polarity of signal being maintained at the speaker output relative to the original mic feed(s). It is based
on each individual recording. Properly set up Sasha 2s should show obvious differences between positive and inverted polarity on most tracks. If they do not, see above.

Bill


Thanks bill.

The first thing i notice with reverse polarity with sasha to is the loss
Of its time coherence which we all value so much, compared to other
Speakers; it still sounded very good regardless of polarity.

I am also baffled; compared to my last speakers (vivid giya g3 ) coherence
Is on par with reversed polarity wilson, whereas others tend to sound
Weird and downright unpleasant; my sasha 2 still sounds fantastic.

If i read you correctly; you think i’m enjoying this present set up
Because i may need to properly position my speakers to the last
Minute? Although my room right now wont allow that; it sound damn
Good to my ears. whereas my vivig gave me all sort of trouble in my
Small room, my sasha is a piece of cake.:banana:

tima 08-24-2019 07:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supermerio (Post 977275)
Thanks bill.

The first thing i notice with reverse polarity with sasha to is the loss
Of its time coherence which we all value so much, compared to other
Speakers; it still sounded very good regardless of polarity.

I am also baffled; compared to my last speakers (vivid giya g3 ) coherence
Is on par with reversed polarity wilson, whereas others tend to sound
Weird and downright unpleasant; my sasha 2 still sounds fantastic.

If i read you correctly; you think i’m enjoying this present set up
Because i may need to properly position my speakers to the last
Minute? Although my room right now wont allow that; it sound damn
Good to my ears. whereas my vivig gave me all sort of trouble in my
Small room, my sasha is a piece of cake. Omit banana

I think the idea is if you want to use your speakers the way they are designed to use by Wilson, don't reverse the wires/polarity

The key to any Wilson speaker is the setup - exacting placement and time alignment. If you have a Wilson dealer in your locale/country, ask them to come to your house to adjust your speakers for optimal sound in the room you have. They are trained in how to do this. You should, imo, hear them at least once with the Wilson setup to have a basis for comparison to your own tweaks - you may be surprised.

Masterlu 08-24-2019 07:33 PM

:goodpost:

Supermerio 08-25-2019 01:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tima (Post 977309)
I think the idea is if you want to use your speakers the way they are designed to use by Wilson, don't reverse the wires/polarity

The key to any Wilson speaker is the setup - exacting placement and time alignment. If you have a Wilson dealer in your locale/country, ask them to come to your house to adjust your speakers for optimal sound in the room you have. They are trained in how to do this. You should, imo, hear them at least once with the Wilson setup to have a basis for comparison to your own tweaks - you may be surprised.

Thank you.

as i’ve said, cant do an optimal or precise adjustment due to my room
Limitation. It still sound very good though and i’m very satisfied.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:41 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.10
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
©Copyright 2009-2023 AudioAficionado.org.Privately owned, All Rights Reserved.